Pages

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

"Being Alive vs Having a Life"

Ethicist Erich Loewy challenges me with the following:

"You are standing in front of a building which is on fire and two things are trapped in it: the one a happy carpenter with three children and the other a Petridish with developing stem cells. You can only rescue one. What would you do?"

Here is an answer some person might give:

""I would not rescue either because they are of equal worth."

What answer would you give? Is simply being alive the same as being aware of and participating in a life? ..Maurice.

1 comment:

  1. When presented with this dilemma, my 8 year old grandson answered simply "you save the life of the carpenter who is holding on to the Petri dish."
    Out of the mouths of babes.. ..Maurice.

    ReplyDelete

Those visitors who want to remain anonymous should nevertheless end their comment with some consistent pseudonym or initials. This is important in order to provide readers a reference to who wrote what and to maintain continuity in the discussions. Thank you. ..Maurice.
NOTICE: This System apparently will not allow Comments to exceed 4096 characters (NOT WORDS). To permit publishing, edit your comments not to exceed that limit.